Which assets from candidate campaigns can be used in independent spend campaigns?
What information can be used in an independent expenditure (IE) campaign depends on who you ask and what laws apply. In recent years, you may have seen candidate campaigns seemingly bending over backwards to publish photos and B-roll videos on their websites (a prime example of this is the 2014 (This is the “McConnelling”). why? What are voters going to do about all this? Well, most of the time, it turns out that your audience isn’t your run-of-the-mill voter at all. These campaigns may instead seek to release information that can be used by independent spending campaigns.
A little context might help. Currently, the Federal Election Commission (commonly known as the FEC, which determines the rules for coordinating federal candidates and IEs in House, Senate, and presidential elections) requires that, if public campaign photos exist, I’m stuck on the question of what it is. Video can be legally used for positive spots with independent expenditure. In the meantime, this fact has led lawyers to reach different conclusions about what exactly the independent spending campaign can spend, and how much.
In the absence of clear guidance from the Federal Election Commission, legal experts have grappled with the permissibility of using campaign materials for independent spending campaigns. The legal community remains divided on this issue. Some legal experts advocate a cautious approach and advise independent spending campaigns to avoid using candidate campaign content, citing potential legal uncertainty surrounding this use. I’m giving advice. This perspective emphasizes the need for independent spending campaigns to source unique visual assets through sources such as Getty Images and commissioned photographers. This cautious stance reflects our commitment to a strong legal footing and to avoid potential legal challenges.
But some legal experts think there may be no need to be overly cautious. They say current law could allow independent spending campaigns to use certain campaign materials that are already publicly available. According to this view, if candidate campaigns actively share content on their websites and social media, independent spending campaigns are likely to use that content for positive purposes. This is why I see so many campaigns going out of their way to make content available, with the possibility that IE will cut TV ads or remove direct mail that helps them. That’s the reason. However, this more relaxed interpretation still emphasizes the importance of having clear rules, such as using content that is truly public and taken directly from official campaign sources.
It is essential to note that the FEC distinction applies only to federal races. With 50 states, there are hundreds of campaign finance laws to contend with in the upcoming gubernatorial race, and each has its own answer to this question. Many companies simply prohibit candidate-provided images and videos from being used in IE, even if the content is public.
As a candidate campaign or IE, you should always consult an election attorney if you have questions about this matter. Given the complex legal landscape surrounding independent expenditure campaigns, it is important to seek advice from a qualified legal professional. Hiring an experienced election attorney can give your campaign a clearer understanding of permissible boundaries and best practices for the use of campaign materials. The importance of aligning campaign strategy with regulatory compliance cannot be overstated, as the consequences of failure can range from financial penalties to reputational damage.
Amid this legal ambiguity, certain “solutions” have emerged within the scope of candidates’ electoral strategies. Some campaigns employ a “red box” concept on their websites to consolidate all publicly available materials into one easily accessible location. This technique provides convenience for independent spend campaigns seeking useful content and can also help highlight issues and positions that are more important to the campaign.
I’ve seen campaigns set up “red boxes” in a variety of ways. This information may be placed on the website’s “Media Center” tab, or in a separate “Photos” section. Depending on your website platform, your campaign may include a direct link to your site to download high-resolution photos. Your campaign page may also link to your Flickr account or Google Drive folder where your high-resolution photos are hosted.
Of course, being publicly available means that campaign photos aren’t only accessible to supported IEs. Your opponent and the IE on the other side must have access as well. It is difficult for IE to use a warm, inviting, smiling photo of a candidate in a negative email. But it’s very easy to take a photo of a candidate standing at a podium or behind a microphone, crop the background, make it black and white, make it a little grainy, and use it in a contrasting piece. The videos could be even more useful to the opposition and its supporters. It’s often not difficult to identify the few seconds a candidate looks unhappy from extensive B-roll footage.
Photos and videos aren’t the only things in these red boxes. I’ve seen some campaigns publish their candidate survey responses. Other campaigns have gone so far as to post completed tally message boxes on their site, detailing their message and the contrasts they can easily create.
As the political landscape continues to evolve, the opportunities available to independent spending campaigns will also change and adapt. As election strategies are developed to increasingly influence politics in this complex environment, legislation is needed to avoid pitfalls and optimize the impact of both independent spending and candidates’ campaigns. Expert guidance remains an essential asset.
The most important thing you can do when planning your own spending campaign is to consult a good lawyer who can advise you on your program. It is better to consult a lawyer than to pay a fine or risk yourself getting bad news.
If you would like to learn more about effective independent spending planning or have any questions about the evolving campaign landscape, please do not hesitate to contact The Campaign Workshop. Our team of experienced professionals is dedicated to providing the expertise you need to navigate the complex world of political campaigns.
Have any questions? Leave us a note.
