When the 2024-25 NHL season is over, the award for the NHL’s best player – the Art Ross Trophy – will be voted upon. Looking at what’s happened thus far in the NHL, two players seem to be the frontrunners for the prize. Connor McDavid‘s always in the mix. However, could Nathan MacKinnon also have a chance this season? He’s sure making a strong case for himself.
Currently, MacKinnon is probably ahead in the Art Ross Trophy race, but with McDavid’s legendary ability to catch fire at any moment, the title of the best player in the NHL remains up for grabs.
A Head-to-Head Comparison Between McDavid and MacKinnon
McDavid’s unmatched speed and agility make him one of the NHL’s most dangerous players. Although, in some ways, he’s a pass-first and score-second player, he can also put up goals. His offensive focus, however, is to create scoring chances rather than finish his chances. He can take advantage of the opposition with his speed alone. In that area, who’s better? No one!
MacKinnon’s a horse. For him, it isn’t just about speed. He can fly on the ice but also brings a gritty edge to his game. Given his size and desire, he can change a game’s momentum in various ways. His strong defensive play is a game-changer, allowing him to contribute on both ends of the ice.
Why McDavid Remains the Frontrunner for the Art Ross
Likely, McDavid’s goal-scoring ability and knack for taking over games just by pushing through the defense to score a goal precisely at the right time make him the favorite to win the Art Ross Trophy. He’s driven. He’s also able to carry the Oilers’ offense.
While MacKinnon might have the statistical edge now, McDavid’s dominance in offensive production cannot be understated. With both players playing at such an elite level, the race for the Art Ross Trophy—and the title of the NHL’s best player—remains wide open. Who will ultimately come out on top? The season’s final months will likely determine whether McDavid can catch up to MacKinnon’s consistency or if MacKinnon can hold his ground. It’s likely about the numbers at the end of the season.
There Are Reasons Why Either McDavid or MacKinnon Might Win
There are reasons why both McDavid and MacKinnon are strong candidates for the title of best player in the NHL, based on their respective strengths. Both players have different abilities and stand out in different ways. McDavid’s exceptional speed, scoring, and playmaking put him at the top offensively, while MacKinnon’s well-rounded game, including his physicality and two-way play, gives him the edge in all-around impact.
Fact or Fiction: The Art Ross Comes Down to Two Choices
As far as we can see, Connor McDavid and Nathan MacKinnon are the two contenders for the Art Ross Trophy this season. But are there other players who could make a surprise push? Could Leon Draisaitl leapfrog his teammate, McDavid, and claim the crown? Or is someone else hanging around that we’ve missed?
And who else might be in the conversation for the top-player title? As the race heats up, it’s worth watching who else might break into the mix. McDavid, MacKinnon, or a surprise to us?
Related: Expect Refs to Make ‘Overcompensation’ Calls After McDavid Fiasco
